Lesson 6: Machine Learning and Bias
In this lesson, students are introduced to the concepts of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning using the AI for Oceans widget. First students classify objects as either "fish" or "not fish" to attempt to remove trash from the ocean. Then, students will need to expand their training data set to include other sea creatures that belong in the water. In the second part of the activity, students will choose their own labels to apply to images of randomly generated fish. This training data is used for a machine learning model that should then be able to label new images on its own.
This tutorial is designed to quickly introduce students to machine learning, a type of artificial intelligence. Students will explore how training data is used to enable a machine learning model to classify new data.
Warm Up (5 mins)
Activity (35 mins)
Wrap Up (5 mins)
Students will be able to:
- Train and test a machine learning model.
- Reason about how human bias plays a role in machine learning.
- Review and complete the online tutorial yourself. If you are not going to use AI for Oceans, explore the other options listed below.
Heads Up! Please make a copy of any documents you plan to share with students.
For the Teachers
- CSP Unit 9 - Data - Presentation
Attention, teachers! If you are teaching virtually or in a socially-distanced classroom, please read the full lesson plan below, then click here to access the modifications.
Warm Up (5 mins)
Goal: Based on yesterdays conversations, answers may vary. Stear the discussion towards conversations around the role that humans play in machines learning. It's ok if the discussion here is short - you are setting the stage for the upcoming activity.
Prompt: How can machines "learn"?
Discuss: Have students brainstorm silently on their own, then have them share with neighbors, and finally have them share out with the room.
Today we're going to be learning more about Machine Learning and its impacts.
Activity (35 mins)
Alternatives to AI For Ocenas: AI for Oceans was orginally developed as an Hour of Code activity that can be completed by students with any device available. We have modified it for its usage here. Depending on your classroom situation, you might opt to replace the activity with:
- Teachable Machines - Teachable Machine is a web-based tool that makes creating machine learning models fast, easy, and accessible to everyone. Teachable Machine is flexible – use files or capture examples live. It’s respectful of the way you work. You can even choose to use it entirely on-device, without any webcam or microphone data leaving your computer.
- If your classrooms devices have cameras, Teachable Machines offers an engaging way to create training sets. Encourage students to teach the machine to represent rock, paper, or scissors with hand gestures. What are some possible ways for bias to enter in?
- Machine Learning for Kids - This free tool introduces machine learning by providing hands-on experiences for training machine learning systems and building things with them. It provides an easy-to-use guided environment for training machine learning models to recognise text, numbers, images, or sounds.
- Machine Learning for Kids is a great option if your students want to work with text samples. Teach the machine to recognize words or passages that are happy or sad. Lots to play around with here!
Video: Play the video "What is Machine Learning".
Machine learning refers to a computer that can recognize patterns and make decisions without being explicitly programmed. In this activity you’re going to supply the data to train your own machine learning model. Imagine an ocean that contains creatures like fish, but also contains trash dumped by humans. What if we could train a computer to tell the difference and then use that technology to help clean the ocean?
Every image in this part of the tutorial is fed into a neural network that has been pre-trained on a huge set of data called ImageNet. The database contains over 14 million hand-annotated images. ImageNet contains more than 20,000 categories with a typical category, such as "balloon" or "strawberry", consisting of several hundred images. When A.I. is scanning new images and making its own predictions in the tutorial, it is actually comparing the possible categories for the new image with the patterns it found in the training dataset.
Do This: Direct students to Levels 3-5 on Code Studio. Students should spend around five minutes total on these levels. Prompt their thinking with the "Consider" on the slide. To program A.I., use the buttons to label an image as either "fish" or "not fish". Each image and label becomes part of the data used to train A.I. to do it on its own. Once trained, A.I. will attempt to label 100 new images on its own, then present a selection that it determined have the highest probability of being "fish" based on its training. Students who consistently label things correctly should see an ocean full of different types of sea creatures, without much (or any) other objects.
Discuss: How well did A.I. do? How do you think it decided what to include in the ocean?
Video: Play the video "Training Data & Bias".
Goal: Get students to reflect on their experience so far. It is important at this point that they realize the labeling they are doing is actually programming the computer. The examples they show A.I. are the "training data".
Prompt: How do you think your training data influenced the results that A.I. produced?
The fish in this tutorial are randomly generated based on some pre-defined components, including mouths, tails, eyes, scales, and fins, with a randomly chosen body color, shape, and size. Rather than looking at the actual image data, A.I. is now looking for patterns in these components based on how the student classifies each fish. It will be more likely to label a fish the same way the student would have if it has matching traits.
In the second half of the activity, you will teach A.I. about a word of your choosing by showing it examples of that type of fish. As before, A.I. doesn't start with any training data about these labels. Even though the words in this level are fairly objective, it's possible that you will end up with different results based on their training data. You might even intentionally train A.I. incorrectly to see what happens!
Do This: Direct students to Levels 7-8 on Code Studio. Students should spend around five minutes total on these levels. Prompt their thinking with the "Consider" on the slide. Here, as before, students will use training data to teach A.I. to recognize different types of fish. The words in this list are intentionally more subjective than what students will have seen so far. Encourage students to decide for themselves what makes a fish look "angry" or "fun". Two students may choose the same label and get a very different set of results based on which fish traits were their focus. Encourage students to discuss their findings with each other or go back and choose new words. Each student will rely on their own opinions to train A.I. which means that A.I. will learn with the same biases held by the students. As students begin to see the role their opinion is playing, ask them to reflect on whether this is good or bad, and how it might be addressed.
Goal: At this point, students should have some preliminary thoughts on how biased data leads to problems for artificial intelligence. They may bring up that if the data sets are trained incorrectly, there will be incorrect or misinterpreted conclusions. It can be addressed through diverse training sets. The following video dives into this subject further.
Prompt: How could biased data result in problems for artificial intelligence? What are ways to address this?
Video: Play the video "How I'm fighting bias in algorithms" with Joy Buolamwini.
- How can computing innovations which make use of Machine Learning reflect existing human bias?
- How could it be used to discriminate against groups of individuals?
- How can that bias be minimized?
As we've seen, problems of bias are often created by the type or source of data being collected. Collecting more data does not mean that the bias is removed. Computing innovations can reflect existing human biases because of biases wirtten into the algorithms or biases in the data used by the innovation.
Machine learning and data mining have led to innovations in medicine, business, and science but information discovered in this way has been used to discrimiate against groups of individuals.
Programmers (that includes you!) should take action to reduce bias in algorithms used for computing innovations as a way to combat existing human biases. Be on the lookout! Bias can occor at any level in software development.
Review: Play the video "Impact on Society" which recaps the concepts discussed today.
Wrap Up (5 mins)
You can share these stories with your class to help them see how AI will impact the future.
- Food Waste Is a Serious Problem. AI Is Trying to Solve It
- AI tech can identify genetic disorders from a person's face
- How an AI Startup Designed a Drug Candidate in Just 46 Days
- MIT AI tool can predict breast cancer up to 5 years early
- The Army steps up its pace on self-driving cars
- San Francisco says it will use AI to reduce bias when charging people with crimes
- AI is helping scholars restore ancient Greek texts on stone tablets
Prompt: Which steps of this process to you think have to be done by humans? Would you be concerned if any of them were automated?
Discuss: Time may be running short at this point in the class. Encourage students to share with a neighbor or share out with the room. The conversation should focus around bias.
At this point, you've fully explored the core parts of the Data Analysis Process. Ultimately you are able to use the new information gained through visualizing and finding patterns (whether yourself or using Machine Learning) to make decisions. This is why being careful about bias is so important!
Assessment: Check For Understanding
Check For Understanding Question(s) and solutions can be found in each lesson on Code Studio. These questions can be used for an exit ticket.
Question: Think about examples of Machine Learning you may have encountered in the past such as a website that recommends what video you may be interested in watching next. Are the recommendations ever wrong or unfair? Give an example and explain how this could be addressed.
CSTA K-12 Computer Science Standards (2017)
AP - Algorithms & Programming
- 3B-AP-08 - Describe how artificial intelligence drives many software and physical systems.
DAT-2 - Programs can be used to process data
DAT-2.C - Identify the challenges associated with processing data.
- DAT-2.C.5 - Problems of bias are often created by the type or source of data being collected. Bias is not eliminated by simply collecting more data.
IOC-1 - While computing innovations are typically designed to achieve a specific purpose, they may have unintended consequences
IOC-1.B - Explain how a computing innovation can have an impact beyond its intended purpose.
- IOC-1.B.1 - Computing innovations can be used in ways that their creators had not originally intended:● The World Wide Web was originally intended only for rapid and easy exchange of information within the scientific community. ● Targeted advertising is
IOC-1.D - Explain how bias exists in computing innovations.
- IOC-1.D.1 - Computing innovations can reflect existing human biases because of biases written into the algorithms or biases in the data used by the innovation.
- IOC-1.D.2 - Programmers should take action to reduce bias in algorithms used for computing innovations as a way of combating existing human biases.
- IOC-1.D.3 - Biases can be embedded at all levels of software development.