Lesson 2: Understanding Your User
Designers need to understand their users’ needs in order to create useful products. This lesson encourages students to think about how to design for another person by role-playing as someone else using a user profile and reacting as that user to a series of products. Each student is assigned a user profile describing a person, which they then use to choose appropriate products, critique product design, and suggest improvements to design.
This lesson builds on the previous by asking students to not only consider that there is a user that products are designed for, but also empathize with those potential users. Throughout this unit, students will work to apply the problem solving process from Unit 1 to problems for other people. Empathy is a key element of this kind of user-centered design and a difficult skill for students at this age to master.
Warm Up (10 min)
Activity (30 min)
Wrap Up (5 min)
Students will be able to:
- Distinguish between their own needs and the needs of their users
- Critique a design through the perspective of a user profile
- Design improvements to a product based on a user profile (not personal opinions)
- Print out enough user profiles for all students, ensuring as much variety as possible
- Print Reacting as your User - Activity Guide for each user
- Prepare prompt questions for warm up exercise
- Label four corners of the room as A, B, C, and D
- Arrange room in table groups of 4, and place a number on each table group (1, 2, 3,...)
For the Teacher
- Understanding the User - Slide Deck
For the Students
- Reacting as your User - Activity Guide
- Profile 1 - User Profile
- Profile 2 - User Profile
- Profile 3 - User Profile
- Profile 4 - User Profile
- Usability - How easy, efficient, and satisfying it is to use a human-made object or device (including software).
Warm Up (10 min)
Usability vs. Aesthetics
Prompt: Are good looking products always easy to use? Can you think of any examples of a product that looked good but was hard to use? What about something that was easy to use, but you didn't like how it looked. Write them down and be prepared to share.
Goal: Highlight that there are many kinds of user needs that we need to empathize with as designers. In particular call out that usability of a product is an important and separate consideration from whether it is merely aesthetically pleasing.
Discuss: Have students journal their thoughts. As they share with their neighbors what they wrote ask them to also discuss whether they care about a product being usable or looking good. After a couple of minutes allow a couple of partners to bubble up what they discussed.
Clearly as users of products we have a lot of needs. It's important as a designer to be able to distinguish among these needs. The usability of our designs will affect whether a user can use the product in the first place. If a product isn't attractive, however, it may never be used at all. As we think more about designing for other people, we'll want to have many different kinds of needs in mind.
Who Am I?
Reducing Printed Materials
The User Profiles are used for reference only. Students can look at digital versions during this activity. Assign each student a link, rather than handing out the actual profiles.
If you choose to print out the user profiles, they can be reused, as long as the students are told not to write on them.
Distribute: Hand students user profiles as they enter class. Instruct students to begin reading over their assigned profile.
Take a few minutes to read over your assigned user profile - you'll need to "get in the head" of your user for our activity today. In fact, for the rest of the day you will be learning to empathize with you users, and respond to situations as your users might.
Circulate: Give students a few minutes to read over their profiles, encouraging them to "get in the head" of their assigned user. For the rest of the day students will be attempting to empathize with their users and respond to situations as their users should
Display: Understanding the User - Slide Deck slides 5-7
For each slide, ask students to choose a corner based on which picture their user would be drawn to. Then have students walk to the corner (A, B, C, or D) that they have chosen to discuss with other students.
Share: Have the groups in each corner briefly discuss (1-2 minutes) why they think their user is drawn to this version of the product. Have one or two students or groups share what they discussed.
Activity (30 min)
Looking Through a User's Eyes
Group: Place students in groups of 3-5 based on their assigned user profile - students with the same profile will be working together through the next activity.
Reducing Printed Materials
Online Option: The Activity Guide can be completed online. Students can "circle" their chosen ratings by putting a border around them, or by typing the rating in the box. For the chair design, students can either draw their design online or submit a paper version of their design separately.
Journal Option: This activity can be completed as a journal entry. Students can use a digital version of the Activity Guide as a prompt, copying the charts and questions into their journals.
Tip: Multiple windows or tabs open on the same computer can be confusing. Have groups work together with one computer displaying the User Profile while another displays the Activity Guide.
Distribute: Reacting as your User - Activity Guide
Adapting the Activity: The provided slides include several products already, but you should add some additional products and images that you think will resonate with your students.
Display: Understanding the User - Slide Deck slides 9-11
Reacting as Your User
Responding to Products
For each product in the slide deck, the groups are going to analyze how their user would react to it by filling out a row in the Reacting as your User - Activity Guide. The guide asks students to make a distinction between the usability of an item for their user and whether a user likes or dislikes it. You may want to go through the first one as a group so you can model that a product may be aesthetically appealing, but not very usable, or usable but not aesthetically appealing.
Share: Have a few groups share out their reactions to each product.
Find a Seat
Display: Understanding the User - Slide Deck slide 12
Students can work individually on the second page, which asks them to consider which of the chairs displayed on slide 12 best fits their user. After reflecting on the features that lead them to choose a specific chair students have a space to design an even more appropriate chair for their user. This is a creative activity, and students can choose to approach it in whatever way is most expressive for them, including drawing their design.
Share: Circle around the room to share some of the chair designs, prompting students to define what specifically makes their design a better choice for their user.
Wrap Up (5 min)
Thinking About Empathy
Journal: Paste or copy your designed object into your journal. Take 1-2 minutes to write about what was easy and what was difficult for you to empathize with your user about.
- What were 3 things about your user that were different from you personally?
- What were 2 times that you found it hard to empathize with your user?
- What was 1 thing you think your user would really like about the chair you designed?
CSTA K-12 Computer Science Standards (2017)
CS - Computing Systems
- 2-CS-01 - Recommend improvements to the design of computing devices, based on an analysis of how users interact with the devices.