Session 33: Addressing Unconscious Bias
60 minutes
discussion-based
Purpose
In the morning we introduced the role that identity and unconscious bias plays in the CS classroom. In this session we build on that foundation. Specifically, this session provides participants with tools and strategies for addressing unconscious bias.
Objectives
- Participants use a shared definition of unconscious bias.
- Participants describe the influence they have over culture and student success in a CS classroom.
Supplies & Prep
Room Setup:
- None
Facilitator Supplies:
Participant Materials:
- Writing utensil
- Journal
- Computers
Agenda
- Strategies to Counter the Impact of Unconscious Bias (51 minutes)
- (2 minutes) Introduce the Protocol
- (32 minutes) Allow participants to engage in the protocol
- (7 minutes) Debrief - full group discussion
- What does this mean for us as computer science teachers? (9 minutes)
- (1 minute) Transitional Remarks
- (8 minutes) Reflection and Discussion
Facilitation Guide
Strategies to Counter the Impact of Unconscious Bias (51 minutes)
Remarks
(1 minute) This morning we talked about the role unconscious bias can play in our classrooms and our teaching practice. While being aware of our biases is the first step in addressing the impact of these biases, we want to provide you with other steps you can take to address unconscious bias.
Have participants navigate to the article “Unconscious Bias: When Good Intentions Aren't Enough".
(9 minutes) Give participants nine minutes to read the article and to identify a passage or idea that feels most significant to them. Participants may want to identify a back-up passage if they like.
Facilitator Tip
If your group does not break evenly into groups of four, consider making some groups of 3 and giving participants time to discuss as a small group openly at the end of their rounds.
More information about the activity
This activity was inspired by "The Final Word" protocol from the School Reform Initiative. You can find the full protocol here.
(2 minutes) Introduce the Protocol
Remarks
Today we are going to be using a protocol to share out in your table groups. For this protocol, you will need one person to keep time. The protocol will follow these steps:
-
The first person begins by reading what struck them the most from the article. Have this person refer to where the quote is in the text - one thought or quote only. Then, in less than 3 minutes, this person describes why that quote struck them. (For example, why do they agree/disagree with the quote? What questions do they have about that quote? What issues does it raise for them? What do they now wonder about in relation to that quote?)
-
Continuing around the circle, each person briefly responds to that quote and what the presenter said, in a minute or less. The purpose of the response is:
- To expand on the presenter’s thinking about the quote and the issues raised for them by the quote
- To provide a different look at the quote
- To clarify the presenter’s thinking about the quote
- To question the presenter’s assumptions about the quote and the issues raised (although at this time there is no response from the presenter)
-
After going around the circle with each person having responded for less than one minute, the person that began has the “final word”. In no more than one minute the presenter responds to what has been said. Now what are they thinking? What is their reaction to what they have heard?
-
The next person in the circle then begins by sharing what struck them most from the text. Proceed around the circle, responding to this next presenter’s quote in the same way as the first presenter’s. This process continues until each person has had a round with their quote.
(32 minutes) Allow participants to engage in the protocol
Facilitator Tip
This debrief is intentionally left open. With a highly-structured protocol, this debrief is used to allow people to both process the process and the content of the discussion. You do not need to “cover” all of these questions. There is no right answer to these questions.
(7 minutes) Debrief - full group discussion
- What surprised you about using this process to discuss this article?
- What did you learn from listening to others’s perspectives?
- What else is on your mind after going through this process?
What does this mean for us as computer science teachers? (9 minutes)
(1 minute) Transitional Remarks
Remarks
Our role as computer science teachers gives us power over who feels like they belong in our CS classrooms. Power comes with responsibility. We are all responsible for identifying and working towards overcoming our unconscious biases that impact who feels like they do and do not belong in our CS classrooms.
(8 minutes) Reflection and Discussion
Prompt: Given your role and power as the teacher what steps or actions can you personally commit to in order to work toward understanding or addressing bias and belonging in your computer science classroom?
- (1 minute) Think: individual reflection
- (2 minutes) Pair: discuss with a partner
- (5 minutes) Share: share and discuss with the whole group
End the session by thanking participants for their reflections and participation during this session.